SUVs have become increasingly popular in the auto industry over the years. But are there really some overrated SUVs? These days, almost every carmaker—even high-end brands like Rolls-Royce and Lamborghini—includes at least one SUV in their lineup. A couple of decades ago, that idea would’ve seemed unlikely.
While SUVs are often marketed as a perfect blend of efficiency and style, some models get more hype than they deserve. While flashy marketing can convince you that the latest SUV is the best option on the market, reality often reveals a different story.
But not all that glitters is gold. Some SUVs, despite their hype, are a complete waste of money and fall short of expectations. Here are a few we think you should skip and we’ll suggest smarter alternatives:
List Of Overrated SUVs:
- Audi Q4 E-Tron.
- Cadillac XT4.
- Dodge Hornet.
- Jeep Cherokee.
- Jeep Compass.
- Land Rover Discovery Sport.
- Nissan Pathfinder.
- Tesla Cybertruck.
- Volkswagen Atlas.
- VW Tiguan.
1. 2024 Audi Q4 E-Tron
Why It Fails to Impress:
The Audi Q4 E-Tron promises luxury and performance in an electric package, but don’t be fooled. With a starting price around $50,000, its range is somewhat underwhelming at about 250 miles—especially compared to competitors. Moreover, its high maintenance costs can leave your wallet feeling lighter—after all, luxury comes with a price.
A Smarter Choice:
For a superior electric driving experience, take a look at the 2024 Polestar 4. While it starts at a slightly higher price point of $56,000, it delivers exceptional value with an impressive electric range of up to 310 miles. Its spacious interior puts it in direct competition with larger models like the Audi Q6 e-tron, but at a more accessible price and with remarkable features to match.
2. 2024 Cadillac XT4
Why It Fails to Impress:
The Cadillac XT4 positions itself as a compact luxury SUV, but it often feels more like a bulked-up sedan. With a starting price of $42,000 and a disappointing reliability rating from Consumer Reports, many owners report subpar performance and cramped rear seating .
A Smarter Choice:
Consider the 2024 Acura RDX as a better option. Starting at around $46,050, which is again slightly higher than the XT4, the RDX delivers a well-rounded package with superior performance, a more spacious cabin, and generous tech features, making it a worthy competitor in the luxury segment
3. 2024 Dodge Hornet
Why It Fails to Impress:
The Dodge Hornet may attempt to make a bold entry into the compact SUV market, but it falls flat with disappointing interior quality and average performance. With a starting price of about $33,000, it seems like more of a marketing gimmick than a practical vehicle.
A Smarter Choice:
Consider the 2024 Mazda CX-50 instead. Starting at around $32,000, it offers a winning combination of impressive performance, a refined interior, and a well-thought-out design. While it doesn’t provide significantly more space than the compact Dodge Hornet, its additional features, intuitive controls, and overall packaging make it a standout option for those prioritizing both style and functionality.
4. 2024 Jeep Cherokee
Why It Fails to Impress:
We’re referring to the discontinued Jeep Cherokee, last produced in 2023. While it once had a strong reputation for off-roading, recent models tell a different story. With a reliability score of just 2 out of 5 and no longer in production, your only choice is to purchase a used model. A 2023 Jeep Cherokee can be found for as low as $27,000, but keep in mind its struggles with performance and fuel economy, averaging just 21 mpg. There are far better options available, whether you’re shopping for new or used vehicles.
A Smarter Choice:
The 2024 Subaru Outback stands out as a superior choice, with a starting price of about $31,000, boasting a reputation for reliability and off-road capability. Offering excellent fuel efficiency (up to 30 mpg), spaciousness, and better safety ratings, it’s the clear winner for adventurous souls.
5. 2024 Jeep Compass
Why It Fails to Impress:
The Jeep Compass tries to bring a rugged feel to the compact SUV segment, but with low reliability records, mediocre performance, and a cramped cabin, it fails to live up to the hype. Starting at approximately $27,000, it offers poor value given its limited cargo space .
A Smarter Choice:
Consider the 2024 Subaru Crosstrek as an alternative. Priced similarly, but it provides excellent features, a roomy cabin, and far better cargo capacity, all packed in a stylish design that makes it a favorite among compact SUV buyers.
6. 2024 Land Rover Discovery Sport
Why It Fails to Impress:
While the Land Rover Discovery Sport is celebrated for its upscale image, it comes with a heavy price tag (starting around $50,000) and low reliability ratings. Many owners report expensive repairs coupled with disappointing fuel economy (only 22 mpg combined) .
A Smarter Choice:
The 2024 Volvo XC60 represents a smarter choice here. Starting around $48,000, it combines Scandinavian elegance with rigorous safety features, offering a more dependable and enjoyable driving experience.
7. 2024 Nissan Pathfinder
Why It Fails to Impress:
Nissan’s Pathfinder takes itself seriously as a family SUV, but with a bland interior and performance that doesn’t excite, starting prices around $38,500 may seem a bit steep for what you get. The Pathfinder’s fuel economy (21 mpg combined) is also nothing to write home about.
A Smarter Choice:
The 2024 Kia Telluride is a much better option. Priced starting at $37,500, it boasts a luxurious interior, excellent third-row space, top-notch safety ratings, and superior overall value, turning every family trip into a memorable journey.
8. 2024 Tesla Cybertruck
Why It Fails to Impress:
The Tesla Cybertruck has captured attention with its futuristic design, but with a base price of $82,000 paired with an unpredictable release timeline, many find it more hype than substance. Plus, its unique design might not appeal to everyone, steering them away.
A Smarter Choice:
The 2024 Rivian R1S is a more compelling option. Priced from around $77,700, it combines sleek design, impressive electric range, and outstanding off-road capabilities that truly set it apart. For the 2025 model year, it earned the prestigious IIHS Top Safety Pick+ rating—a distinction not yet available for the Cybertruck.
9. 2024 Volkswagen Atlas
Why It Fails to Impress:
While the Volkswagen Atlas boasts impressive interior space, it lacks the necessary refinement. With a starting price of around $39,600, it suffers from low reliability scores and subpar performance, making it less appealing than its competitors .
A Smarter Choice:
The 2024 Honda Pilot, starting at approximately $41,000, provides better performance alongside an upscale interior. Its reputation for reliability and family-friendly features makes it a valuable investment for any family.
10. 2024 Volkswagen Tiguan
Why It Fails to Impress:
The VW Tiguan has been marketed as a versatile compact SUV, yet it often disappoints with unreliable performance. With a reliability rating of only 2 out of 5 and starting costs around $30,000, owner satisfaction is frequently low.
A Smarter Choice:
Consider the 2024 Toyota RAV4 Prime as a viable alternative. Starting at about $33,300, it equips buyers with superior fuel efficiency, smooth ride dynamics, and a wealth of safety features—all in a dependable package.
Key Takeaways
- Audi Q4 E-Tron: Overpriced with limited range. Choose Polestar 4.
- Cadillac XT4: Poor performance and cramped seating. Go for Acura RDX.
- Dodge Hornet: Lacks quality and refinement. Opt for Mazda CX-50 instead.
- Jeep Cherokee: Low reliability and fuel efficiency. Consider the Subaru Outback.
- Jeep Compass: Mediocre performance and cramped space. Try the Subaru Crosstrek.
- Land Rover Discovery Sport: High price and low reliability. Check out Volvo XC60.
- Nissan Pathfinder: Bland interior and performance. Switch to Kia Telluride.
- Tesla Cybertruck: Overhyped design without substance. Try Rivian R1S.
- Volkswagen Atlas: Low reliability with high costs. Opt for Honda Pilot.
- VW Tiguan: Uninspiring performance and low ratings. Choose Toyota RAV4 Prime.
Final Thoughts
Sometimes these SUVs sound great or look cool thanks to their names or ads, but they usually don’t measure up when it comes to important stuff like how reliable they are, how well they perform, or if they’re worth the price. If you check out the other options we’ve mentioned, you can save some cash and have a way better experience as a driver. So think it through and hit the road with confidence!
If you found this post useful, you might also enjoy our article, “Top 10 Longest Lasting SUVs You Can Buy Today.” Our site offers detailed car reviews, expert buying guides, and the latest industry insights to keep you informed. Take a look around, and be sure to bookmark our homepage for future updates!
*Disclaimer: This website provides automotive content for informational purposes only and should not be considered professional advice. While we strive for accuracy, we do not guarantee the reliability or suitability of any vehicle or product mentioned—always conduct your own research before making purchasing decisions. Additionally, some links on this site are affiliate links, meaning we may earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no extra cost to you.